Judge in Marshall County HS shooting case responds to allegations

PADUCAH- Circuit Judge Jamie Jameson is defending decisions he has made so far in the deadly Marshall County High School shooting case.

Jameson currently oversees the case of 15-year-old Gabriel Parker. Parker is charged as an adult and is accused of opening fire in the commons area of the school on January 23.  15-year-olds Bailey Holt and Preston Cope died in the shooting. 18 other students were wounded.

Paxton Media Group, which owns WPSD-TV, filed two petitions for a writ of mandamus or prohibition earlier this month. The first alleges serious misconduct by Judge Jameson, claiming he is acquainted with the suspect’s mother. It also says Jameson appointed a public defender despite having no legal authority to do so. In that filing, PMG asked the Kentucky Court of Appeals to override Jameson’s actions to close the arraignment and seal the records.

PMG filed a second petition accusing Judge Jameson of overseeing a secret hearing with no prior docket entry or public notice. It also accuses Jameson of issuing a gag order, then sealing the order so no one could view it. This filing requests the Court of Appeals to void the gag order and make records of circuit court proceedings available to the public.

On Monday, we received a copy of Judge Jameson’s response for the Court of Appeals. He claims both petitions lack evidence and states he has acted within his authority and according to the law. He argues serious misconduct was, rather, “differences of opinion on legal matters.”

In his response, Jameson gave a timeline of events, including appointing Parker’s public defense attorney, Bethany Willcutt, and having a conference call on February 19 with no notice to the public. Willcutt no longer represents Parker. Tom Griffiths is his acting attorney and as such took part in the February 19 call.

Jameson stated Willcutt approached him within hours after the shooting and said she planned to request her employer, the Kentucky Department of Public Advocacy, appoint her to represent Gabriel Parker. Jameson states Willcutt was contacted by Parker’s mother , who was concerned Parker was being questioned in custody without an attorney. Jameson says he appointed Willcutt without any objections from Commonwealth Attorney Mark Blakenship. Jameson argues, since Parker’s case was not filed in any court at that point, he could make the appointment as judge of the court of “general jurisdiction.”

Jameson also acknowledged knowing Parker’s mother, but argues there is no personal relationship, stating he only knows her as a reporter for a local news outlet.

In the timeline Jameson provided, he stated he acted within the law, which “compels confidentiality of records until the juvenile defendant ‘has been indicted and arraigned.’” Despite both events happening, those records are still sealed. Jameson argues the court is not obligated to unseal the records immediately. Jameson did state that during the arraignment Tom Griffiths, now Parker’s acting attorney, challenged Parker being charged as an adult.

Jameson also acknowledged he did have a conference call with Griffiths and Assistant Commonwealth Attorney Jacob Ford on February 19. He argued conference calls are often permitted to speed up legal matters. He says the parties agreed to keep all records from the juvenile part of the case sealed until he reached a decision Griffiths’ challenge.

Jameson also defended the sealed gag order we described in our petition as unconstitutional. He argues that it is no longer relevant because it expired after Parker’s arraignment.

Jameson addressed that Paxton Media Group suggested Jameson recuse himself, arguing such a request must come from the defendant or prosecution. The prosecution requested a special judge be appointed last week.

Paducah Sun Editor and Publisher Jim Paxton says the next stop will likely be oral argument before the Court of Appeals, but the court could decide before that based on the filings.

You can read Jameson’s first response by clicking here.

You can read Jameson’s second response by clicking here.

Related Articles

Mayfield announces Project Safe Neighborhoods Project Safe Neighborhoods connects local, state and federal officials to reduce gun violence across the country.
City and county react to PACRO and PED changes Paducah Economic Development says it's waiting for notice of the Paducah Area Community Reuse Organization's contract termination. That's just one asp...
Kentucky Wired over budget and behind schedule Over budget and behind schedule — that's how state Sen. Danny Carroll describes a years-long effort to improve internet access across Kentucky. 
University of Kentucky student suspended after child’s death The University of Kentucky has suspended a student and the fraternity he pledged after the death of a 4-year-old boy hit by the student's car.